Watch: The SoHo Forum Debate at The Sheen Center in NYC September 15, 2025  

More Resources: Review our companion resource guide from the debate.

Proposition: Paying for sex should be a crime. Taking the negative against Melanie Thompson. We each had 15 minutes to make our case, 5 minutes to rebut, 40 minutes of Q&A and then 5 minutes to close.

 


 

Opening Remarks from Kaytlin Bailey: Is It Ok To Pay For Sex?

Paying for sex should not be a crime.

My opponent has dedicated her life to trying to make sure that what happened to her never happens to anyone else. We both want a safe, healthy society where everyone has access to the resources they need to make choices about their own lives.

But arresting people who pay for sex does not help victims. Instead it makes violence and exploitation within the sex industry more likely and harder to prosecute.

Paying for sex is not inherently violent or exploitative. It is paying for a service, like hiring a nanny or someone to clean your home. Paying people for advertised services, even intimate or unpleasant ones, is not abuse.

Treating service providers cruelly, abusing or coercing them to do things they didn’t sign up for is wrong, regardless of what the work is. We cannot support survivors if we are unable or unwilling to distinguish between paying customers and violent criminals.

The overwhelming majority of people involved in commercial sex are consenting adults.

And that isn’t just based on my experience; it’s in the arrest data. Of the tens of thousands of people arrested every year in the US for prostitution related offenses only a small minority, less than 6%, involve trafficking or lead to trafficking charges.

In NYC, where laws create compelling incentives and multiple opportunities for defendants to identify themselves as trafficking victims, 80% of people arrested for prostitution do not.

I was a sex worker.

The thought that the kind, generous people who respectfully paid for my time would be hunted and put into a cage breaks my heart.

Clients help pay bills, fund education and start businesses. These are not predators, they’re people.

I had a client who was recently widowed, who felt too fragile to date. He only wanted to be held and cry. It’s a tragedy that this man did not have friends or family he could turn to–but he didn’t. And you can feel uncomfortable with the idea of a strange, bereaved man sobbing into my arms but I am proud that my profession was able to offer him, and many people like him, a non judgemental place to cry.

I met a young man with cerebral palsy, in his mid-thirties in Detroit. He and his mother drove from Ohio to see me perform. The only sexual experiences he’s had have been with sex workers.

In Ohio, if he had sent an email to an undercover cop instead of a compassionate professional, he could have been charged with a felony. And his mother could have been charged too, just for driving him to an appointment.

That’s what criminalizing sex buyers looks like.

My opponent wants you to believe most clients are monsters. Which is simply not true.

Decades of research—including the work of Dr. Barbara Brents, one of the leading scholars on the sex industry published the largest comparative study of clients in the US and the UK—shows the opposite.

According to data, most clients are not violent. They are reasonable, normal people seeking connection.

If clients were as monstrous as prohibitionists claim then people would not keep choosing this work. Consensual adult sex workers exist. In large numbers. All over the world. We build businesses, advertise our services, negotiate with our clients and try to take precautions against the risks of our job, many of which are the direct result of criminalization.

Going after consenting adults for private behavior not only ruins lives but it also makes it harder to prevent violence and get victims the support they need.

Criminalization makes it harder to catch predators because people in a criminalized economy don’t report suspicious activity to the police. Black markets are notoriously dangerous. That’s as true of the prohibition of alcohol as it is of sex work.

The promise of end demand laws, or making paying for sex a crime, is that it is a progressive, compassionate alternative to criminalizing sex workers. And that we can eliminate an industry no one wants to be in.

In reality, everywhere these laws have been implemented prostitution still exists and violence within the sex industry gets much, much worse.

Think about what it would be like to try to work in a place that was actively trying to eliminate your livelihood. Where you have to lie to your landlord, and probably your doctor. Where you can’t seek help from a social worker or the police. Where it is illegal to rent to you, or for you to have colleagues or share information. And where your customers are jumpy and unwilling to comply with standard industry safety practices because they are the ones who might be arrested.

These laws isolate sex workers even when they don’t directly criminalize us.

Sweden criminalized “sex buyers” in 1999 in an effort to end demand and eradicate the sex industry. Of course, like abortion, they did not end prostitution they only made it less safe.

Northern Ireland tried the same thing in 2015 and a government report showed that the law had no impact on demand, but it did increase violence against sex workers.

In places where paying for sex is a crime so is renting to a known sex worker. When social workers or the police find that someone is selling sex they threaten their landlord to get them evicted.

Selling sex is considered a form of self harm and good mothers lose their children if they continue.

When clients are criminalized, so are the people we work with. Sharing which hotels will let you rent rooms, or where to get free condoms, or bad client lists is considered “promoting prostitution.” And sex workers who work together are charged with pimping.

End demand laws push the entire sex industry further underground. These laws not only take away our livelihood, they also undermine the strategies we use to keep ourselves safe.

When clients fear arrest they are less likely to share identifying information, comply with screening efforts, or communicate clearly. Sex workers have to take risks to appease nervous clients making it more difficult for us to distinguish between the clients we want and predators we want to avoid. Despite what prohibitionists would have you believe-there is absolutely a distinction.

When paying for sex is a crime sex workers live in a constant state of terror that they will lose—not just their livelihood—but their homes and their children. Sex workers in these countries are not afraid of their clients, they are afraid of their government and the real life impact of these so-called end demand laws.

Last year, 18 states in the US increased penalties for buying sex.

People are being convicted of felonies just for answering an ad. Law enforcement agencies are investing real time and money—not investigating reported rapes—but setting up fake ads pretending to be sex workers and targeting immigrant-owned businesses, especially Asian massage parlors.

The overwhelming majority of people who are arrested for soliciting are poor men of color because policing prostitution looks like every other kind of policing and it doesn’t look like justice for victims.

Mass incarceration is one of our greatest failures as a country. The US puts more people in cages, per capita, than any other developed nation. Criminalizing clients will only make this worse—filling prisons not with rapists or traffickers, but with people entrapped by police posing as sex workers.

Incarceration is a necessary evil for violent offenders but we should not expand the definition of rape to include people like my clients or the many people I know who treat the sex workers they hire well.

Between 12-14% of men, and 1%, of women have paid for sex. That’s more than 16 million people and over a million women, my opponent believes should be locked up.

Tools used to “end demand” are tools of surveillance. When paying for sex is a crime, the police will use their considerable resources, not to support victims of rape or domestic violence, but to track who we pay, who we have sex with and restrict what we can find online. The technology to do this already exists. Giving law enforcement more power to invade our private lives is not feminist or progressive, it’s dystopian.

But there is a policy that upholds the human rights of sex workers and reduces violence. Because when you take an underground industry out of the shadows, health and safety improves.

This isn’t just a theory. New Zealand, many states in Australia and Begium decriminalized sex work. When RI stopped arresting people for buying or selling sex between 2003-2009 STI rates dropped 40% and violence against women dropped 30%. And when craigslist erotic services made it easy for sex workers and clients to communicate, the female homicide rate dropped 17%.

When buying, selling, and facilitating sexual services is not a crime sex workers are able to find and share information, advocate for their own safety and health and access the services and support they need.

Which is why organizations like the WHO, Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, the ACLU and the Freedom Network, the largest service provider for trafficking victims in the United States, support the full decriminalization of sex work. Because it is the only policy that reduces violence.

The data is clear. If the goal is to reduce gendered violence, STI’s and encourage victims to work with law enforcement than we should decriminalize adult consensual sex work.

Sex workers in New Zealand can, and do, report crimes without fear of arrest. The police in New Zealand do not stalk sex workers looking to arrest their clients, they do not put together elaborate stings to humiliate people. They respond to complaints from victims of domestic violence or assault and they take those complaints seriously whether the victim was selling sex, or not.

Predators exist. We can and should arrest people who prey on sex workers and vulnerable people. But we cannot do that if we keep conflating respectful clients with violent criminals.

What we can do is listen to victims when they report crimes. Every dollar we spend arresting consensual adults for engaging in consensual sex work is a dollar not spent pursuing predators.

Melodie and I both want to live in a society where all people, whether they have ever sold sex or not, have access to the services and support they need to avoid exploitation and stay safe.

We even support some of the same bills here in New York that would make life better for sex workers and victims of trafficking alike.

One of them is an immunity law that would allow people to report crimes without fear of arrest for prostitution related charges.

This is a law that, if signed, will help catch rapists, traffickers and even serial killers. It’s a common sense, bipartisan, bill that has already passed the Assembly and the Senate, it only needs Governor Kathy Hochul’s signature.

Melanie and I both support this bill because laws that help sex workers also help survivors.

Sex workers want many of the same things victims of trafficking want. We want access to resources, and to be able to report crimes. We want access to healthcare, housing and the banking and technology services we all use everyday. All of which makes it harder for traffickers and abusers to operate.

But here’s where Melanie and I differ. She and other prohibitionists believe that paying for sex is violence in and of itself. That we should use policy to try to eliminate sex work entirely. I believe that sex that would not otherwise be a crime should not become a crime just because someone is getting paid.

I have been raped. And I have been paid for sex. Those experiences were profoundly different.

Most clients are not violent. Rape and assault exist in, and out of the the sex industry. Because sexual violence is everywhere.

I was sexually harassed in every restaurant I worked in, by customers and managers alike. I have been date-raped, I have been abused by boyfriends.

And nearly every woman I know—many who have never exchanged sex for money—have similar stories. Ending the sex industry, even if it were possible, would not end misogyny or sexual violence.

But freeing sex workers to report crimes committed against us, to make and keep our money and allowing us to contribute our wisdom and our talents to the communities we are already a part of, might.

You don’t have to be someone who would ever buy or sell sex to know that people chose to do this work, and will continue to do this work, whether they, or their clients, are criminalized.

We have decades of data that shows that decriminalizing sex work not only reduces violence and STIs, but also creates opportunities for sex workers to hold people accountable who try to hurt us.

We can make it easier to report sex crimes. We can prosecute predators and fund real resources for people fleeing violent partners or abusive employers.

But we will not do any of that by arresting people for paying for sex.